ARTICLES / General /Driving Dilemmas: Risk vs. Independence /
Other Articles
Driving Dilemmas: Risk vs. Independence
By Kristine Dwyer, Staff Writer
Dementia and Driving Cessation
Alzheimer’s disease and driving safety is of
particular concern to society. Alzheimer’s disease
(AD) is the most common cause of dementia in later
life and is a progressive and degenerative brain
disease. In the process of driving, different
regions of the brain cooperate to receive sensory
information through vision and hearing, and a series
of decisions are made instantly to successfully
navigate. The progression of AD can be unpredictable
and affect judgment, reasoning, reaction time and
problem-solving. For those diagnosed with
Alzheimer's disease, it is not a matter of if
retirement from driving will be necessary, but when.
Is it any wonder that driving safety is compromised
when changes are occurring in the brain? Where
dementia is concerned, driving retirement is an
inevitable endpoint for which active communication
and planning among drivers, family, and health
professionals are essential.
Current statistics from the Alzheimer’s
Association indicate that 5.3 million Americans have
Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and this number is expected
to rise to 11-16 million by the year 2050. Many
people in the very early stages of Alzheimer’s can
continue to drive; however, they are at an increased
risk and driving skills will predictably worsen over
time. The Alzheimer’s Association’s position on
driving and dementia supports a state licensing
procedure that allows for added reporting by key
individuals coupled with a fair, knowledgeable,
medical review process.
Overall, the assessment of driving fitness in
aging individuals, and especially those with
dementia, is not clear cut and remains an emerging
and evolving field today.
Physician’s Role in Driving Cessation
While most older drivers are safe, this population
is more prone to vehicle accidents due to decreased
senses, chronic illness and medication-related
issues. The three primary functions that are
necessary for driving and need to be evaluated are:
vision, perception, and motor function. As the
number of older drivers rises, patients and their
families will increasingly turn to the physicians
for guidance on safe driving. This partnership seems
to be a key to more effective decision-making and
the opinions of doctors vs. family are often valued
by older drivers. Physicians are in a forefront
position to address physical, sensory and cognitive
changes in their aging patients. They can also help
patients maintain mobility through proper counseling
and referrals to driver evaluation programs. This
referral may avoid unnecessary conflict when the
doctor, family members or caregivers, and older
drivers have differing opinions. (It should be noted
that driver evaluation programs are usually not
covered by insurance and may require an
out-of-pocket cost.)
Not all doctors agree that they are the best
source for making final decisions about driving.
Physicians may not be able to detect driving
problems based on office visits and physical
examinations alone. Family members should work with
doctors and share observations about driving
behavior and health issues to help older adults
limit their driving or stop driving altogether.
Ultimately, counseling for driving retirement and
identifying alternative methods of transportation
should be discussed early on in the care process,
prior to a crisis. Each state has an Area Agency on
Aging program that can be contacted for information,
and referrals can be made to a social worker or
community agency that provides transportation
services.
Printable Version